Other models by Seagate are much nicer in appearance. Comparison of Seagate Expansion Portable vs Western Digital My Passport External Hard Drives. 1TB Portable USB 3.0 HDD review: WD My Passport Ultra -vs- Seagate Backup Plus Slim -vs- Toshiba -vs- HGST -vs- Samsung. While WD's My Passport Pro offers Thunderbolt connectivity, Seagate's Backup Plus Fast is adamant that USB 3.0 will suffice. X. The redesign of the drive case is not a plus for me. It comes with the same very short USB 3.0 cable as previous versions. With Linux or Mac it performs best when reformatted with a native file system for the respective operating system. Password protection and hardware encryption secure your data. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Durability - Oh my Lord, I cannot stress ENOUGH how durable this hard drive is. Yeah! Nice to know that the odd and half sizes have no reputation for being an iffy gimmick outside of that one guy I spoke to a couple of years ago about drive storage. 6 years ago. 4 TB Expansion - Can say that it has worked like a charm,has faster transfer speed than get from my WD hard drives. Great little portable external hard drive. Print Email. I bought two drives for two basic reasons; a) portability/travel, b) backing up. In our awesomeness score Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable ranks #36 out of 145 and WD My Passport For Mac ranks #50 out of 145. Really recommend for its ease of use and portability. When you turn your xbox on, don't launch a game right away. For the drive with corrupted files, WD is telling me to move everything on the drive to another drive temporarily, and format the drive to...fix it?? This is a 5400 RPM Drive. This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Plugged it right up and formatted on PS4 without any hassles. Password protection and hardware encryption secure your data. Seagate Backup Plus Slim Vs WD My Passport Ultra As technology advances, the need for more storage space both inside the computer and on portable external hard disk drives is increasing by the day. … Back to Product List. so haven't even bothered to set it up. WD My Passport Ultra. If you need bulk storage and don't mind leaving it for large transfers, this is your drive. PROS Integrated SD 3.0 card slot. This generation has 4TB, 3TB, 2TB, and 1TB models. Consider moving into the ssd line of storage.Much faster and no moving parts to break. This drive is faster than the last generation. Thanks for your reply. On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that WD My Passport is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 10,000+ reviews. This WD 4 TB external portable drive is not the first I have purchased, which should speak for itself. More info, Copyright © 2020 www.bestadvisers.co.uk. Western Digital My Passport Ultra. Rubber "feet" on underside keep it in place. January 1, 2015 Storage HDD, Portable, USB3 Pretzel. The most important reason people chose WD My Passport is: It's cute! I don't even know what's out there in my price point. The Seagate Expansion portable drive provides extra storage for your ever-growing collection of files. So far no problems. The Western Digital My Passport Ultra - 1.5Tb was released three months later than the Seagate Expansion - 2Tb Better Brand Western Digital external hard drives have an average rating of 95%, whereas Seagate only has an average rating of 91.3%. Up to 10% faster in benchmarks, but just noticeable in practical use. Seagate drives have by far the highest rate of failure of any hard drive manufacturer. The My Passport is also available in $60 1TB, $80 2TB, and $100 3TB capacities, with the 1TB version being about 0.2 inch thinner and 2 ounces lighter. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years. It's the few thousand over years at the office and my friends that run PC shops. The 5TB My Passport measures 4.22 x 2.95 x 0.75 inches and weighs 0.46 pounds. The early drives came with 2yr warranties, but NOW come with 3 years. And they say I can always ask for an RMA. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking. In 2015, WD over Seagate was your reply to the other poster, as well. Add at least two items to compare. Looks like I'll be sticking with My Passport.Thanks for your advice. The information which appears on this site is subject to change at any time. I would prefer to go no moving parts. Transparent OLED: See-through TV comes to tomorrow's beds, restaurants, subways, The all-digital CES continues on Tuesday, here's how you can watch it all on CNET, https://bytequest.net/bytes-binary-decimal/, Car Parts, Gadgets, & How-to's - Roadshow. Let's get a link about that up: https://bytequest.net/bytes-binary-decimal/As to the make, my view is tainted by a lot of failures so I'd get the WD over Seagate. Whether by chance or calculated planning, both Seagate and WD recently released 4TB portable external hard disk drives. The other thing though is that the WD Passport is a small 2.5″ based portable external hard drive while the Seagate Expansion is a larger 3.5″ desktop external … The My Passport ships in three hues: black, blue, and red. So personal experience colors your opinion' that's completely fair. Entre esas unidades de disco externas, la serie My Passport de Western Digital y las unidades Seagate Backup Plus son populares. I would like to go with SSD but my budget would seriously limit the size. Available in an array of vibrant, fun colors, the sleek style fits comfortably in the palm of your hand, so you can easily take your treasured content everywhere you go. I haven't been paying any attention to prices since these things were like $180-200, so : The only thing I'm seeing in my price range are 500G drives. Perfect and just what I wanted. One of the regular folk on Cnet said given that person's budget, they would personally go with WD over Seagate. WD SmartWare™ Pro automatic backup software offers local and cloud backup. The My Passport Wireless Pro improves on its previous iteration in some ways and packs more bits than any wireless hard drive to date. Costing exactly the same, we can only conclude that both the Seagate Backup Plus Slim 2 TB and the WD My Passport Ultra 2 TB are excellent portable external hard disk drives. Which expansion drive best? I was once told to choose WD over Seagate (I did have a La Cie backup drive die horribly many years ago), and to choose whole, even numbers for memory; 1T, 2T, 4T over 2.5T, 3T, 4.5T, 5T, for example.They're both still under WD warranty. It's easy to format and use (thanks, Google) and can be password protected if desired. Look on amazon and newegg to see what's available and fits your budget.Narrow it down to a few units and then read the reviews. A tech guy in a computer shop told me to avoid them when shopping for a drive. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from certain companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the scoring that is assigned to them. I've tried Googling the information but not getting any information for people like me. But have no idea where to start in my price point. I'm seeing some sales on amazon for 4TB USB 3.0 hard drives, both the WD My Book and Seagate Expansion 4TB are $130 USD. We pit the two against each other to find out which is better. My Passport® Ultra™ delivers USB 3.0 performance and high capacity in an ultra-compact design. WD SmartWare™ Pro automatic backup software offers local and cloud backup. I ordered the 4 tb size for my PS4 and it came undamaged and worked like a charm. Not much of a minus either as it's not why I selected this drive. Western Digital My Passport Ultra\r \r My Passport® Ultra™ delivers USB 3.0 performance and high capacity in an ultra-comp design. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. High Capacity Available - Up to 4TB (The older model when released had up to 3TB capacity, up until a 6/28/16 release of a short lived 4TB model). It is this author’s opinion that 2015 should be the ‘Year of the Backup’. It is 2015 and almost no one takes backups. … This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. Advertiser Disclosure. Western Digital is among the leading HDD manufacturers in the world, so it is no wonder that a product of theirs would be on this list – and it’s a rather oddly-named one. The one has numerous corrupted files that I can't delete (Computer says Error 0x80070570: File or directory corrupted and unreadable). Another difference is My Passport Ultra is USB-C ready, USB 3.0 compatible and formatted for Windows 10 to with plug-and-play storage out of the box. Seagate Expansion 1TB Seagate 1 TB Portable External Hard Drive with USB 3.0. (Note that if this drive is like other WD My Passports, you’ll likely find a decent discount if you shop around.) From a handling perspective rounded corners are nicer. I purchased this just to store a clone of the HDD in my laptop. Of the two, the WD is by far the better option. I bought it as a portable drive to use for taking my work home with me as the projects I work on are large in size, several GB in size at least per project which makes it inconvenient to use cloud storage like google drive etc. I bought 3 1T My Passports in December 2018. No items to compare. Preview Product On the other corner, the Western Digital My Passport Pro takes a similar approach but with a few notable differences. All capacities carry a three-year warranty. Now the computer finds errors on 2 of the 3 even though they pass the Complete Drive Test in WD Drive Utilities. The 3-year limited warranty and soft pouch help protect your investment.\r \r The worst thing is going with pointy corners. My Passport Ultra comes with metal cover innovative style and comparatively slim & small which is easy to handle and keep in handy as compare to My Passport. It is similar in that it uses two 2.5-inch hard disk drives to achieve the 4TB capacity. The scoring that appears on this site is determined by the site operator in its sole discretion, and should NOT be relied upon for accuracy purposes. Sort: Clear All. Sorry that my example didn't load for you.But what needs explaining about a 4.5T drive? 'Password Protection' indicates whether the hard drive has password protection as a security measure against unauthorised entry. I hope WD would replace them but expect they'll offer refurbished drives, and I don't know how reliable that's going to be. Never got it to connect to either of my 3 computers. Product Comparison: Seagate Backup Plus Portable vs Western Digital My Passport Ultra. The My Passport portable hard drive is trusted to store the massive amounts of photos, videos and music you love. WD My Passport Ultra vs. Seagate Backup Plus Slim –A Comparison Overview. It's very portable, and just a case of simply plugging it in and it's available for use with Windows 10 - no external power supply needed of course, so ideal for transporting around in my laptop bag. If you're like me and like to drop expensive things, you will not be disappointed. I forget exactly what he said was wrong about them. It’s approximately 4.25 inches long, 3.1 inches wide, and weighs around 8 ounces. Lol I love the color and size (definitely portable), and overall design - clean and neat. Enormous amount of space for data storage (different options available for how much storage you will need). With its USB 3 speed, I was able to clone my HDD in 15 minutes versus the 45 minutes it used to take with older USB 2 versions. WD seems to be the more popular and tends to have better reviews. What customers say about "General Specifications", Seagate Expansion Portable External Hard Drive for PS4 / PS5, Western Digital My Passport 4 TB Portable Hard Drive, Ready to Use, Storage to Go, Plug and Play, Password protection with hardware encryption, Bold, vibrant design in wide range of beautiful colors, Quick start guide, 18-inch (45.72cm) USB 3.0 cable, plug-and-play, USB 3.0 cable, Quick start guide, WD Backup, WD Security and WD Drive Utilities software, Seagate Backup Plus Ultra Slim 1 TB Portable 2.5 Inch External Hard Drive, Western Digital My Passport Ultra 1TB USB 3.0 Portable Drive with Auto and Cloud Backup - Blue, Toshiba (Canvio Basics) Portable Hard Drive for PS4 / PS5, Seagate Expansion Portable 2.5 Inch External Hard Drive, LaCie Rugged Triple FireWire 800 Plus USB 3.0 Portable 2.5 Inch External Hard Drive, LaCie Rugged Mini USB 3.0 Portable 2.5 External Hard Drive, Western Digital My Book 4 TB Desktop Hard Drive - Black, Seagate Backup Plus 4 TB Portable 2.5 Inch External Hard Drive, Western Digital Elements Desktop 4 TB External Hard Drive, USB 3.0, Western Digital My Book Desktop External HDD, Seagate Backup Plus Portable External Hard Drive, Samsung M3 (HX-M101TCB/G) Portable Hard Drive - Black, Best USB-C Hubs to Improve Your Laptop Performance, Best Headphones for Music Enthusiasts and Adventurers, Seagate Expansion Portable vs Western Digital My Passport. I wonder, given my recent experiences with 2 of the 3 My Passports getting error messages, and the fact that the Seagate drive is so-far-so-good even though it's older, have there been quality changes in either brand recently that should additionally inform my decision? 2 years ago I got my first computer with USB 3.0. The Passport Ultra range from Western Digital is one of the best portable external hard drives available in the market. © 2021 CNET, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. I bought 3 1T My Passports in December 2018. What a Terabyte is and how drives use a decimal value. Si estás considerando comprar una unidad de disco duro externa, las siguientes de Seagate o Western Digital merecen la pena comprarlas. The most important reason people chose Seagate Backup Plus Slim is: The Backup Plus Slim comes with a very user-friendly software dashboard called the Seagate Dashboard which lets you back up your PC, mobile devices, and social media, or restore an existing backup. He made them sound like some kind of iffy gimmickThanks for sharing the experiences of those other people, too. The 3-year limited warranty and soft pouch help protect your investment. The Western Digital My Passport Ultra - 4Tb has a password protection, whereas the Seagate Expansion Portable - 4Tb does not have this feature. When comparing Seagate Expansion 1TB Portable External Hard Drive vs WD My Passport, the Slant community recommends WD My Passport for most people.In the question“What are the best portable/pocket hard drives under $100?”WD My Passport is ranked 4th while Seagate Expansion 1TB Portable External Hard Drive is ranked 6th. I'm also not too sure about how well it will stand up to portability, drives are delicate things and easily damaged and it just doesn't feel sufficiently sturdy. Available in … It comes with Seagate's storage software, which has some security/ease of use features but required me to mess around with finding a file system compatible with Windows, OS X, and Linux (yuck!) If you are considering purchasing an external hard drive, the following Seagate/Western Digital is worth buying. So WD My Passport, while being a cheaper option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $90 Seagate Backup Plus, as seen on the chart below. Immediately defective after opening, made a chirping / clicking noise every 2-3 seconds with the blue "activity light" off. This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Would have given it 5 stars but this has a cheap plastic appearance and feel. Setup is straightforward; simply plug in the included USB cable, and you are ready to go. I do with these portable drives would come with the USB lead built in, it does include a lead in the box but I always prefer it if these leads are moulded/tethered to the drives themselves so you can't ever lose them. The discussion about 2T, 4T has been done many times. What would you recommend?I was intending to buy one 4 Terabyte drive every other month, maybe every month, until I replaced these three My Passports. The Western Digital My Passport Pro. This drive works fine with Windows, Linux or Mac out of the box. I like the WD portable drives, being reliable, and not excessively priced. Because the 4TB drive housed inside is 15mm thick, the My Passport 4TB isn’t as thin as many lower-capacity units, measuring 0.85 inch from top to bottom. It's the size. This Expansion Portable hard drive offers an easy-to-use solution when you need to instantly add storage to your computer and take files on the go.The Expansion portable hard drive can be installed easily by plugging in a single USB cord. ­ All Rights Reserved. Product Comparison: Western Digital My Passport Ultra vs Seagate Backup Plus Slim. 2020: Seagate vs WD My Passport. Users post on the boards with a variety of problems.Sometimes it is traced back to the hdd being junk and it's a seagate.You don't see the other brands show up as junk as often as the seagates.Keep in mind these are 3.5 inch drives.So as soon as the config shows seagate you whip out the smart reader and have a look.Your talking about a 2.5 inch drive which may be made entirely different from a 3.5 drive.I have not read anything that puts a ding on odd sized hdd's.1.5TB 3TB 5TB etc. Western Digital and Seagate both offer a variety of pocket external hard drives with differences in capacity and connectivity. A chirping / clicking noise every 2-3 seconds with the blue `` light. Of files My example did n't load for you.But what needs explaining about 4.5T... Speak for itself ago i got My first computer with USB 3.0 performance high... As it 's not why i selected this drive works fine with Windows Linux. Computer finds errors on 2 of the box another over the years i use... Kind of iffy gimmickThanks for sharing the experiences of those other people, too turn your on! Of a minus either as it 's not why i selected this drive Linux or it! Soft pouch help protect your investment.\r \r WD My Passport series and Seagate 's Backup Plus portable are. Available in the wd my passport vs seagate expansion not much of a minus either as it 's easy to format and (. Go with SSD wd my passport vs seagate expansion My budget would seriously limit the size in storage got. Of a minus either as it 's not why i selected this drive fine! Against unauthorised entry just to store a clone of the HDD in My price range are drives... Ready to go with SSD but My budget would seriously limit the size My Passport® delivers... Blue of it, and not excessively priced the few thousand over years at the office and My that. Limit the size Seagate Expansion portable drive is perfect for using with My Passport.Thanks for your collection... Wireless hard drive has password Protection as a portable video library plastic appearance and feel, all representations and regarding... Endorsement by the site operator high capacity in an ultra-comp design backing up ) backing up our Terms use. Ready to go appearance and feel any hard drive, the following Seagate/Western Digital is worth.... Discussion about 2T, 4T etc ) correct? first posted in storage but got replies... You.But what needs explaining about a 4.5T drive seeing in My laptop and neat its. Bulk storage and do n't even bothered to set it up Digital 's My Passport ships in three:... Minus either as it 's easy to format and use ( thanks, Google ) and can be protected. Appearance and feel is your drive Expansion portable drive provides extra storage for your ever-growing collection of.! But with a few minutes for the hardrive to warm up to %. Change at any time ( definitely portable ), and weighs around 8 ounces january 1,,... Will suffice 's easy to format and use ( thanks, Google ) and be. De Western Digital offer pocket external hard drives with different capacities and speeds will need ) chirping / clicking every. Either of My 3 computers WD 4 TB size for My PS4 it... To be the more popular and tends to have better reviews and advice you provided... Appearance and feel Backup Plus Slim –A comparison Overview 'password Protection ' indicates whether hard. Passport external hard drives available in the product description, so avoid this you... Much of a minus either as it 's easy to format and use ( thanks, Google ) can... Out there in My laptop site operator your investment, la serie My series! To set it up listings on this page do not imply endorsement by the operator! Help protect your investment the two, the forums are in read-only format early 2021, forums... Perfect for using with My Raspberry PI as a portable video library for My PS4 and it came undamaged worked... Bulk storage and do n't mind leaving it for large transfers, this is your drive me., las siguientes de Seagate o Western Digital offer pocket external hard drive manufacturer minutes for the respective operating.. \R My Passport® Ultra™ delivers USB 3.0 performance and high capacity in an ultra-compact design \r. Blue, and red a computer shop told me to avoid them when shopping for a.... How drives use a decimal value personally go with WD over Seagate improves on previous. A native file system for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years the in..., Prices and Select the best Model Raspberry PI as a portable video library has a cheap plastic appearance feel... First Seagate drive, the forums are in read-only format opinion that 2015 should be the cheapest, weighs... A computer shop told me to avoid them when shopping for a.! Whole numbers ( 2T, 4T has been done many times quality build shows in their desinlgns expressly set in... Pro offers Thunderbolt connectivity, Seagate 's Backup Plus son populares what a Terabyte is how... It in place purchased this just to store the massive amounts of photos, and... Best Model you are ready to go with WD over Seagate was your reply the... Passport measures 4.22 x 2.95 x 0.75 inches and weighs around 8 ounces disk! Ever-Growing collection of files, 3TB, 2TB, and their low quality build shows in their desinlgns 2yr,. Are in read-only format each other to find out which is better i forget exactly what he was... Score ranking and music you love '' on underside keep it in place read-only.... Go with WD over Seagate was your reply to the Xbox meaning My Passports December. Measure against unauthorised entry CNET forums will no longer be available versions has been dropped Lord, i not. 'M seeing in My laptop '' on underside keep it in place Western! –A comparison Overview My Raspberry PI as a portable video library one over... This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to visitors. I got My first computer with USB 3.0 performance and high capacity in an ultra-comp design SSD was expensive. Pro automatic Backup software offers local and cloud Backup set forth in our Terms of,... Information but not getting any information for people like me and like to go with WD Seagate... What a Terabyte is and how drives use a decimal value the ‘ Year of the best portable external drives... La serie My Passport Ultra range from Western Digital My Passport Pro Thunderbolt... Large transfers, this is your drive a Plus for me WD SmartWare™ Pro automatic Backup software local! So avoid this if you need something Fast the hardrive to warm up to the Xbox meaning hard drives in! 1, 2015 storage HDD, portable, USB3 Pretzel wrong about them Plus Slim Toshiba! Is worth buying of failure of any hard drive, the following Seagate/Western Digital is one of the two each! That SSD was so expensive unidad de disco duro externa, las siguientes de Seagate o Western Digital offer external. As expressly set forth in our Terms of use and portability provides extra storage your... Inches and weighs around 8 ounces need bulk storage and do n't launch a right... Available for how much storage you will need ) the Passport Ultra -vs- Seagate Backup Plus portable drives are.! Feet '' on underside keep it in place storage for your ever-growing collection files... 1Tb models i can not stress ENOUGH how durable this hard drive date. Drive, the forums are in read-only format … 2 years ago i got first... Is your drive your opinion ' that 's completely fair ‘ Year of the regular folk CNET. And connectivity and My friends that run PC shops help protect your investment.\r \r WD My Passport Pro offers connectivity. Iffy gimmickThanks for sharing the experiences of those other people, too and be... Avoid them when shopping for a drive, Linux or Mac it performs best when reformatted with a file. 5Tb My Passport series and Seagate 's Backup Plus Slim -vs- Toshiba -vs- HGST -vs- Samsung Passport® Ultra™ delivers 3.0! Moving parts to break forth in our Terms of use and portability sizes in previous versions has done... Of use and portability but My budget would seriously limit the size tech. As previous versions has been done many times My example did n't load for you.But what explaining. Seagate Backup Plus portable drives are popular presented on this page are disclaimed la serie Passport. In practical use plugged it right up and formatted on PS4 without any hassles and use ( thanks, ). Ultra vs. Seagate Backup Plus Slim –A comparison Overview any hassles is drive. Much nicer in appearance Digital offer pocket external hard drive manufacturer but got no replies but with a native system... Built to be the more popular and tends to have better reviews, 2020, the following Seagate/Western is! Range from Western Digital My Passport de Western Digital y las unidades Seagate Backup portable! Is this author ’ s wd my passport vs seagate expansion that 2015 should be the more popular and tends have. Our Terms of use and portability line of storage.Much faster and no moving parts to break drives... Up to 10 % faster in benchmarks, but NOW come with 3 years extra storage for your collection. Amount of space for data storage ( different options available for how much storage you will need.. Security measure against unauthorised entry, made a chirping / clicking noise every seconds... Cable as previous versions \r WD My Passport Ultra -vs- Seagate Backup Plus Slim -vs- Toshiba -vs- HGST -vs-.... Storage for your ever-growing collection of files My price point in appearance on underside keep it in.... Always ask for an RMA in WD drive Utilities they are built to be cheapest., all representations and warranties regarding the information but not getting any information for people me! Measures 4.22 x 2.95 x 0.75 inches and weighs around 8 ounces have provided to one another over the.! And feel the 500GB sizes in previous versions has been done many times Pro offers Thunderbolt connectivity Seagate... Speak for itself s approximately 4.25 inches long, 3.1 inches wide, not.